Hi,
I am just getting stuck into this. Looking at Echo Dot + Harmony Hub + Sonos Play 1 (x2).
A few strange issues as I work through the Activities and Scenes relationship, but I’m more or less there.
One frustration relates to Harmony not picking up Sonos playlists in My Sonos. Spotify playlists, imported playlists, albums and radio stations are all presented but not Sonos playlists created in Sonos from My Library. Odd!
Question: is there any way to clear up rubbish scenes in bulk or do I have to delete them individually?
Andy
Two part answer to your question.
Regarding Sonos and Harmony Hub, initially, before, I got the Echo, I was not happy with the Harmony / Sonos integration because the Harmony app gave less control than the Sonos app on the same devices. When I first installed the Echo as a Canadian device, I had to use the Harmony Hub to have Alexa turn Sonos on and off, but, after that it was pretty flaky. When I completed the US setup, then I was able to invoke the Sonos Skill for Alexa. This is better but not perfect.
Alexa can turn Sonos on and off, pause, volume control and select music. It seems to have some trouble with playlists or searching for music. For example I say Alexa play Todd Rungren music from Spotify on Sonos, she says can’t find Todd Rungren. Then I set up a Todd Rungren playlist in Spotify, she still can’t find the playlist, but if I say Play Todd Tungren music, now she plays the playlist.
Regarding the Rubish Scenes, the first time I set it up, I got all kinds of Scenes I did not want. Alexa seems to have a mind of its own. Through trial and error, I noticed a few things. If you want to delete an activity from Harmony, first delete the scene from Alexa, otherwise, Alexa will keep the scene even if it points to nothing. I got a lot of scenes created from a random list of favourite TV channels that Harmony had created, so I had to clean that up first.
I forced the Harmony Activities on those items that I really want to turn on and turn off. For detailed control I still use the Harmony remote or the App. After starting over a few times, I got it down to a reasonable list of scenes in Alexa that I can manage with.
Note, so far I have not found a good way to edit the scenes in Alexa other than delete. You only get one chance to add simple names to scenes when you first implement the Harmony skill and do the initial discovery. Adding scenes later you get whatever Alexa come see up with.
I expect this to improve over time. I hope this helps.